FastCounsel

Detailed answer — clear steps to take now

When an insurer stops updating you or threatens to close your claim, act quickly and methodically. The goal is to preserve evidence, document the insurer’s conduct, and use the Wyoming Department of Insurance if necessary. Follow these steps:

1. Review your policy and the claim file.

   Read your insurance policy to confirm covered losses, required deadlines (notice, proof of loss), and any conditions you must meet. Locate your claim number, adjuster name, and all correspondence from the company.

2. Document everything.

   Make a single, organized file (digital and paper) that includes: policy declarations page, claim number, all emails and letters, a log of phone calls (date, time, person spoken to, summary), photos, repair estimates, receipts, and proof of mitigation actions (e.g., temporary repairs).

3. Request a written status update and next steps.

   Send a short, clear written request to the claims adjuster and the insurer’s claims department asking for a written status update, the reason for any threatened closure, what is needed from you to avoid closure, and a deadline. Send by email and by certified mail with return receipt so you have proof of delivery.

4. Comply with reasonable requests promptly.

   Provide requested documents or access for inspections in a timely way. If you cannot meet a deadline, notify the insurer in writing and explain why with an estimated date of completion.

5. Push back on improper closures.

   If the company claims it will close the file, ask for the exact reason in writing (e.g., insufficient proof of loss, claim inactivity, policy exclusion). If you disagree, reply in writing with relevant supporting documents and ask them to keep the claim open while they re-evaluate.

6. Escalate internally.

   Ask to speak with a supervisor or the claims manager. Use the insurer’s complaint or escalation process. Keep records of the escalation and any promised timeframes.

7. File a complaint with the Wyoming Department of Insurance.

   If the insurer ignores you, mishandles the claim, or threatens closure without a valid reason, file a consumer complaint with the Wyoming Department of Insurance. The Department can investigate unfair claim handling and may intervene on your behalf. Wyoming’s insurance laws and regulatory oversight fall under Title 26 of the Wyoming Statutes (Insurance). See the Wyoming Department of Insurance website for consumer complaint procedures: https://doi.wyo.gov. For the state insurance statutes, see Title 26: https://wyoleg.gov/statutes/title/26.

8. Consider independent inspections and estimates.

   Get an independent adjuster or licensed contractor estimate. If an appraisal provision exists in your policy, you may be able to trigger an appraisal process to resolve disputes over the amount of loss.

9. Preserve your rights and evidence promptly.

   Don’t sign broad releases or settlement documents without understanding them. Keep all receipts and records of mitigation and repairs you perform. These items matter if you later pursue administrative remedies or litigation.

10. Talk to an attorney if needed.

    If the insurer’s conduct appears dishonest, unreasonable, or violates policy terms, consult an attorney experienced in insurance claims and bad-faith practices in Wyoming. An attorney can explain available remedies, statutory protections, and any applicable deadlines. Because deadlines and remedies vary by claim type and facts, get legal advice early.

What protections exist under Wyoming law?

Wyoming’s insurance statutes and the Department of Insurance regulate insurer conduct, including claims handling. The Wyoming Department of Insurance accepts consumer complaints and enforces state insurance laws. For a starting point, see Title 26 of the Wyoming Statutes (Insurance): https://wyoleg.gov/statutes/title/26. For help from the regulator, visit the Wyoming Department of Insurance: https://doi.wyo.gov.

When might legal action be appropriate?

If the insurer denies or closes a valid claim without a reasonable basis, intentionally misapplies policy terms, or unreasonably delays payment, those facts can support administrative complaints and possibly civil claims against the insurer. Potential remedies can include payment of covered benefits, interest, and in some cases additional damages and attorneys’ fees depending on the claim and statutes. Because remedies depend on the policy wording and facts, discuss your situation with a Wyoming attorney.

How to file a consumer complaint with the Wyoming Department of Insurance

1. Gather your policy, claim number, all communications, estimates, receipts, and a short written timeline of events.
2. Visit the Wyoming Department of Insurance website for consumer complaint instructions and an online form: https://doi.wyo.gov.
3. Submit the form and follow up if you get no response within the Department’s stated timeline. Keep copies of everything you submit.

Disclaimer

This information explains general steps under Wyoming law and is not legal advice. It does not create an attorney-client relationship. For legal advice about your specific situation, consult a licensed attorney in Wyoming or contact the Wyoming Department of Insurance for consumer assistance.

Helpful Hints

• Keep a written log of every call: date, time, name, and summary.
• Send important requests and documents by certified mail and email for proof of delivery.
• Ask the insurer in writing what will prevent them from closing the claim and how long they will keep it open after your response.
• Don’t sign any full-release settlement without independent advice if the scope is unclear.
• Obtain an independent repair estimate to compare with the insurer’s position.
• If you get an unsatisfactory response from the insurer, file a complaint with the Wyoming Department of Insurance and attach your documentation.
• Act quickly — some administrative and legal deadlines run strictly. If in doubt, consult a lawyer early.