Virginia: How to Get an Auto Insurer to Reopen a Closed Claim

FAQ — Reopening a Closed Auto Damage Claim in Virginia

Short answer: Act quickly. Review your policy, gather documentation showing the claim was closed improperly or that new damage/evidence exists, send a written request to the insurer asking it to reopen the file, escalate inside the company if needed, and if the insurer refuses or ignores you, file a complaint with the Virginia State Corporation Commission (SCC) Bureau of Insurance and consider consulting an attorney.

Detailed answer — step-by-step process

1. Confirm what happened and preserve evidence

Check your policy and the claim file. Locate any letters, emails, text messages, the claim number, adjuster name and contact information, inspection reports, and the insurer’s final disposition or closure notice (if any).
If you did not receive formal notice of closure, collect proof of non-receipt (e.g., no delivery of mail, missing emails). Note dates when you first learned of the closure or discovered additional damage.
Take photos and keep repair estimates, repair shop notes, invoices, receipts for towing or storage, and any medical records if injuries are involved.

2. Understand possible reasons the insurer closed the claim

Adjuster concluded no coverage exists, the loss is not covered, or the damage was minimal and already paid.
Insurer believed you abandoned the claim or failed to cooperate.
Clerical or administrative error caused premature closure.
New evidence (e.g., additional damage discovered later) supports reopening.

3. Contact the adjuster and insurer promptly — use written communication

Call the adjuster to get an explanation. Then immediately follow up in writing (email or certified mail) summarizing your call and your request that the insurer reopen the claim.
In your written request, state why the claim should be reopened (new damage, missed inspection items, error, or lack of notice). Attach supporting documents and a clear timeline.
Keep copies and track delivery/receipt dates. Written communications create a record that helps later appeals or regulatory complaints.

4. Use the insurer’s internal appeal or complaint process

Most insurers provide a formal internal appeal or dispute resolution process. Ask for the appeals instructions and deadlines, and submit your appeal with all supporting documentation.
Ask that your file be assigned to a supervisor or a different adjuster for review.

5. Cite consumer protections and cite the law when appropriate

Virginia law prohibits unfair claim settlement practices. You can cite Virginia Code § 38.2-510 when arguing the insurer acted improperly. See the statute: Va. Code § 38.2-510.
Pointing to the statute can prompt a more careful internal review, but it does not guarantee a settlement. Keep arguments factual and evidence-based.

6. If internal escalation fails, file a complaint with Virginia’s insurance regulator

If the insurer refuses to reopen or does not respond within a reasonable time, file a complaint with the Virginia State Corporation Commission (SCC) Bureau of Insurance. The SCC can investigate unfair practices and mediate some disputes.
Locate the SCC consumer pages for insurance complaints and submission instructions on the SCC website (search for “SCC Bureau of Insurance consumer complaint” or visit the SCC’s insurance/consumer pages at https://scc.virginia.gov/).

7. Preserve your right to sue — know timing and next steps

If your insurer wrongfully denies coverage or unreasonably refuses to reopen a claim, you may have legal claims for breach of contract or for unfair claim practices. Virginia has statutes of limitation that apply to contract and tort claims, so act before deadlines run.
Consult a Virginia attorney promptly to evaluate whether to send a demand letter or file suit. An attorney can assess damages, procedural deadlines, and whether bad faith or unfair practices occurred.

8. Consider alternative dispute resolution

Depending on your policy and the insurer’s willingness, mediation or arbitration can resolve disputes faster than litigation. Your insurer may propose one of these options.

Sample written request to reopen a closed claim (use as a template)

[Your name]
[Your address]
[Your policy number]
[Claim number]
[Date]

To: [Insurance company name and claims manager]

I request that you reopen Claim #[claim number]. On [date] you closed the claim without prior notice to me. Since closure I have discovered additional damage/new evidence: [brief description — photos, repair estimates attached]. I have attached: photos, repair estimates, communications with the adjuster, and any other supporting documents.

Please confirm in writing within 10 business days that you will reopen and reassign this claim for a full review. If you decline, please state the specific basis for denial and identify any additional information you need from me.

Sincerely,
[Your name]
[Contact information]

Helpful Hints

Always make requests and appeals in writing and keep copies.
Send important letters by certified mail (return receipt) or by email with read receipt when available.
Document every phone call: date, time, person spoken to, and what was said.
Get independent repair estimates and repair shop documentation to support claims of missed damage.
Be concise and factual in communications; avoid accusatory language but cite facts and statute when relevant.
If the claim involves possible fraud or misrepresentation by the insurer, consider contacting an attorney earlier rather than later.
If the insurer closed the claim due to lack of cooperation, promptly provide any outstanding documents the insurer reasonably requested.

Where to get help in Virginia

For consumer assistance and to file a complaint: Virginia State Corporation Commission (SCC) — Bureau of Insurance. Visit the SCC website at https://scc.virginia.gov/ for complaint forms and contact information.
Consider consulting a licensed Virginia attorney experienced in insurance disputes to review your policy, claim file, and legal options.

Disclaimer: This article explains general steps under Virginia law and is for educational purposes only. It is not legal advice. Consult a licensed Virginia attorney or the SCC Bureau of Insurance for advice about your specific situation.

FastCounsel