Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer. This article explains general information about Utah law to help you decide whether to consult an attorney. It is not legal advice.
Detailed Answer
If you were injured and the insurance company gave you a “final” settlement offer that you believe is too low or otherwise unfair, you have several options under Utah law. The proper steps depend on whether this is a first‑party claim (your own insurer, such as for health, PIP, or homeowner coverage) or a third‑party claim (another person’s liability insurer). Below is a practical, step‑by‑step process to contest that final offer and preserve your rights.
-
Pause—do not sign anything immediately
Insurance companies often ask claimants to sign a release in exchange for a payment. A release typically ends your right to pursue additional money for the same injury. Before you sign, get a written, itemized explanation of the payment and the release terms. If the settlement is labeled “final,” treat it as a serious decision.
-
Gather and organize your evidence
Collect all medical records, bills, receipts, photographs of injuries or accident scene, police reports, employer wage statements showing lost earnings, and any written communications with the insurer. Organized evidence strengthens a counteroffer or a court filing.
-
Ask for an itemized breakdown and the insurer’s basis for the offer
Send a written request asking the company to explain how it calculated the offer: what amounts it credited for medical bills, lost wages, property damage, diminished earning capacity, pain and suffering, and what legal arguments or policy limits it used. Put your request in writing and keep proof of delivery.
-
Make a reasoned counteroffer or demand letter
Prepare a short demand letter or counteroffer that summarizes your injuries, attaches supporting documentation, states the total damages (medical bills, future care, lost wages, non‑economic losses), and explains why the insurer’s offer is insufficient. Include a deadline for response (e.g., 14 days). A clear, supported demand can reopen negotiations.
-
Consider alternative dispute clauses in the policy
Check the insurance policy for an appraisal clause or mandatory arbitration provision. Some policies require appraisal (usually for property loss values) or arbitration for certain disputes. If your policy contains those provisions, follow the contract’s procedures to trigger them.
-
File a complaint with the Utah Insurance Department
If the insurer will not negotiate or you suspect bad faith or unfair claim handling, you can file a complaint with the Utah Insurance Department. The Department can investigate unfair claim practices and sometimes help resolve disputes. See the Department for consumer complaint guidance: insurance.utah.gov.
-
Talk to a personal injury attorney—many offer a free consultation
An attorney can evaluate whether the insurer’s conduct amounts to a bad‑faith claim or whether you have strong grounds to sue for more damages. In many injury cases attorneys work on contingency (they are paid only if you recover), which reduces up‑front cost barriers.
-
File a lawsuit before the statute of limitations expires
If negotiations fail, you can file a civil action in Utah court. Personal injury limitations in Utah are governed by the state statutes of limitations; consult Utah statutes and a lawyer to confirm exact deadlines for your claim so you do not lose the right to sue. For general information about Utah courts and forms see: Utah Courts Self‑Help.
-
Use mediation, arbitration, or court as appropriate
After filing suit—or sometimes before—parties can use mediation to reach a settlement. If the policy requires arbitration, follow that path. If neither route resolves the dispute, the case proceeds in court for trial.
-
Watch out for liens and subrogation
If a health insurer, Medicare, Medicaid, or a medical provider has a lien or claims subrogation, settling without addressing those liens may leave you responsible for repaying them. Ask for a written statement of outstanding liens before finalizing any settlement.
Legal bases and Utah resources
Utah regulates unfair insurance practices through the Utah insurance code (Title 31A) and related rules. If you believe the insurer engaged in unfair settlement practices, you may be able to file a complaint with the Utah Insurance Department or, in some cases, pursue a civil claim. See Utah Code—Title 31A (Insurance): le.utah.gov – Title 31A. For general civil filing rules and deadlines, consult the Utah Code and the Utah Courts website.
Helpful Hints
- Do not sign a broad release that ends future claims for the injury until you know the full extent of your damages.
- Keep a claims journal: record dates, phone calls, names of adjusters, and what was said.
- Send important communications by certified mail or email and keep delivery/read receipts.
- Get a clear medical prognosis—if your doctor expects future treatment, include those projected costs in your demand.
- If the insurer’s offer is tied to a quick cash payment, ask whether they will escrow disputed amounts instead of asking you to sign away other claims.
- Compare settlement offers to expected net recovery after medical liens, attorney fees, and costs to evaluate whether the offer is truly reasonable.
- If you suspect unlawful conduct by the insurer (e.g., misrepresenting policy language or ignoring relevant medical records), preserve all communications and consider immediate legal advice.
Important Utah links:
- Utah Insurance Department — consumer complaint information and contact.
- Utah Code, Title 31A (Insurance) — state insurance laws and regulations.
- Utah Courts Self‑Help — court forms and filing guidance.
If you want, provide brief facts about your injury, the insurer’s offer, and whether the insurer is your own or a third‑party’s insurer. I can suggest next steps you could discuss with a local attorney.