FastCounsel

Short answer: Yes — a valid prenuptial (premarital) agreement can change how property and spousal rights are handled in South Dakota, and that can affect life‑estate planning or the share you ultimately receive from your mother’s estate. If an executor refuses to provide the agreement or basic probate information, you have steps you can take in probate court to get the document and to hold the executor accountable.

How prenuptial agreements interact with life estates and wills in South Dakota

Prenuptial agreements (agreements made before marriage) generally govern the contracting spouses’ rights in property and can include waivers of rights that a surviving spouse might otherwise claim after the other spouse dies. If your mother and her spouse signed a valid premarital agreement that addresses ownership of certain property, that agreement can control how that property is treated — even if your mother later created a life estate in a will or by deed — provided the agreement was valid when signed and still effective.

Common effects of a valid premarital agreement:

• It can identify certain assets as separate property and exclude them from division on death or divorce.
• It can waive a surviving spouse’s statutory or elective share of the decedent’s estate, if the agreement meets legal requirements for enforceability.
• It can limit or define how property passes at death (for example, directing that certain real property stays separate or is not subject to the will).

How that affects you depends on how the life estate was created and what the prenup actually says. Typical scenarios:

• If your mother already transferred a present life estate in real property (for example: “to my spouse for life, remainder to my child”), that conveyance usually creates a present legal interest that a later‑signed prenup cannot nullify as to already‑transferred third‑party rights. But a prenup could have already limited the spouse’s interest before the life estate was created.
• If the life estate arises from your mother’s will on death, and the prenup validly waived the surviving spouse’s rights to the property or to an elective share, the prenup can prevent the spouse from asserting those rights over property that would otherwise pass under the will or intestacy rules.
• If the prenup assigns property away from the marital estate or requires that certain assets pass to children, it may supersede inconsistent testamentary directions, assuming the prenup is enforceable under South Dakota law.

What makes a premarital agreement enforceable in South Dakota

To affect rights at death, a premarital agreement must be valid and enforceable. Typical legal requirements include that the agreement be in writing and signed by both parties, that the parties entered it voluntarily, and that it was not unconscionable or entered after inadequate disclosure of assets (or without a waiver of disclosure). South Dakota’s statutes on marriage, premarital or marital agreements, and probate govern these rules and how courts treat them. For more on South Dakota probate and related codes, see the South Dakota Codified Laws Title for Probate: SDCL Title 29A (Probate), and for family/domestic relations provisions: SDCL Title 25 (Domestic Relations). If the agreement is missing or was never validly executed, it may have no effect.

Practical points about life estates and what you can expect

• If the life estate was created by deed during your mother’s life, that deed should be part of the county land records; recording creates public notice.
• If the life estate was created by will, the will and related probate filings become part of the probate case and generally are public once the will is filed for probate.
• If the prenup specifically allocated the property at issue to the spouse or otherwise waived your potential remainder interest, a court will likely enforce the agreement if it meets statutory requirements.

What to do if the executor refuses to provide the premarital agreement or estate information

Executors (personal representatives) in South Dakota have fiduciary duties to beneficiaries and to the court once appointed. They must account for estate assets and provide information to interested persons. If an executor refuses to provide copies of a premarital agreement, a will, an inventory, or accountings, you can take the following steps.

1) Ask for the document in writing

Send a clear written request (email and/or certified mail) to the executor requesting a copy of the prenup (and any estate documents you want). Keep a copy of your request and the delivery receipt. A written record helps if you later go to court.

2) Check public records

Look for recorded deeds, recorded life‑estate instruments, or the will filed in probate. County register of deeds and the probate court clerk are the usual places to search. Probate filings (a filed will or the opening of an estate) become public. For South Dakota probate procedures, see: SDCL Title 29A.

3) Ask the probate court to compel production

If the executor was appointed and is administering the estate, you can file a petition with the probate court requesting an order that the executor produce estate records, or you can ask the court to compel the executor to provide an inventory and accounting. South Dakota probate courts have authority to require fiduciaries to produce information to interested persons and to enforce fiduciary duties.

4) Request an accounting or file a motion

If the executor fails to comply, you can ask the court for a formal accounting, entry for discovery, or other relief. If the executor’s refusal amounts to a breach of fiduciary duty, the court can impose sanctions or remove the executor.

5) Consider lawyer help or legal aid

If the estate is large or the issues are contested, consult an attorney experienced in South Dakota probate and estate litigation. An attorney can file the necessary petitions or motions and represent you in court. If you cannot afford a lawyer, check local legal aid resources or the South Dakota State Bar referral services for guidance.

6) Time sensitivity

Act promptly. Probate actions, claims against estates, and some remedies have time limits. Preserve evidence (emails, letters, recorded documents) and act quickly to avoid missing deadlines.

Helpful Hints

• Document every request you make to the executor in writing and keep proof of delivery.
• Search county land records for deeds or recorded life‑estate instruments — those are often easier to find than private agreements.
• Ask the probate court clerk whether a will or opening petition has been filed; probate filings are public and typically include the will and initial inventories.
• Look for language in the will or deed that references an agreement — sometimes wills will note that assets were handled per a premarital agreement.
• If the prenup is missing, the court may permit discovery to produce it if it is relevant; don’t assume it is gone for good.
• Be prepared to show you are an “interested person” (beneficiary, heir, or creditor) — that status gives you standing to ask the probate court for relief.
• If you suspect fraud, coercion, or lack of disclosure in the formation of a premarital agreement, raise those concerns early — those are common grounds to challenge enforceability.
• Keep expectations realistic: courts balance the written terms of valid premarital agreements against statutory protections for spouses and other heirs.