FastCounsel

Detailed Answer

Under Rhode Island law, hospitals, physicians, and other medical providers may assert a lien on personal injury settlements or judgments to secure payment for treatment. This right arises from the Hospital Lien Act, R.I. Gen. Laws § 34-18-1 et seq. These liens attach to third-party recoveries, including settlements and jury awards.

To negotiate down a medical lien and maximize your net recovery, follow these strategies:

1. Obtain an itemized billing statement. Request a detailed invoice from each provider. Review charges line-by-line to identify duplicate or non-covered services.
2. Check for proper statutory compliance. Verify that the provider filed the lien notice within the time limits required by R.I. Gen. Laws § 34-18-2. An untimely lien may be unenforceable.
3. Assess reasonableness of charges. Compare billed rates against fair and customary fees in Rhode Island. If charges exceed norms, request a reduction based on Health Insurance Fee Schedules or published guidelines.
4. Leverage subrogation priorities. Identify whether an insurer or Medicare has subrogation rights. Use the priority structure to argue for proportional lien reduction.
5. Negotiate a percentage holdback. Propose to hold back a negotiated percentage—often 2020%—pending finalization of medical expenses. This gives providers security while preserving liquidity for the client.
6. Engage a lien resolution professional. Some firms specialize in lien arbitration. They use data analytics and regional fee benchmarks to secure steeper discounts.
7. Document communications. Keep written records of all settlement and lien communications. Detailed logs support future arguments about proper notice or delay.
8. Consider filing motions. In contested cases, you may move to reduce or discharge a statutory lien under Rule 6 of the Rhode Island Superior Court, arguing overbreadth or inequity.

Each reduction directly increases the client’s net recovery, enhancing overall compensation.

Helpful Hints

• Request lien statements early—ideally before settlement demand letters go out.
• Use public fee schedules to benchmark reasonableness.
• Be aware of Medicare’s interests to avoid future clawbacks.
• Negotiate with providers who have high administrative overhead first.
• Always verify a provider’s license and lien compliance status.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified attorney regarding your specific situation.