The Short Answer

In Pennsylvania, a “lifetime” easement (or similar lifetime right to use property) is usually a recorded property right that cannot be unilaterally changed just because it became financially burdensome after a later property division. However, it may be possible to end or reshape the arrangement through a negotiated release, or through court involvement if the estate/property interests must be clarified or sold and the easement’s impact has to be addressed as part of that process.

What Pennsylvania Law Says

Easements and other lifetime use rights are generally treated as enforceable interests in real estate. That means the “unexpected costs” problem is usually not solved by simply deciding the deal is unfair after the fact—courts typically look to the recorded documents, the intent of the parties, and how the interest was created (by deed, will, settlement agreement, etc.). In probate-related disputes, the Orphans’ Court may also become involved when the decedent’s real estate interest must be administered, clarified, or sold, and any lifetime rights affecting the property have to be accounted for.

The Statute

The primary law that often comes into play in probate-driven real estate disputes is 20 Pa.C.S. § 3546.

This statute authorizes a petition in Orphans’ Court to determine/establish title to a decedent’s interest in Pennsylvania real estate in certain situations, which can be critical when a lifetime right (like an easement or life-use arrangement) clouds ownership, blocks refinancing/sale, or creates disputes among heirs and co-owners.

If the “property division” you’re referring to is a divorce-related division of entireties property, another statute that can matter is 23 Pa.C.S. § 3507, which addresses how entireties property is held after divorce and the ability to pursue a sale and division of proceeds—issues that can collide with a lifetime easement/right of use.

For a deeper dive into partition/order issues that sometimes overlap with lifetime rights, see: Can I Set Aside or Modify a Prior Partition Order in Pennsylvania?. If co-ownership financing pressure is part of the burden, see: How Do Refinancing and a Buyout Work When You Co-Own a Home in Pennsylvania Probate?.

Why You Should Speak with an Attorney

Even when the law provides a path forward, lifetime easement disputes are fact-sensitive and can become expensive quickly. Legal outcomes often depend on:

• Strict Deadlines: Probate and real estate disputes can be affected by timing (for example, when a petition to determine title is even available under Pennsylvania probate rules, and whether prior court orders or recorded instruments limit your options).
• Burden of Proof: Whether you can change the arrangement often turns on the exact language of the recorded easement/right, how it was created, and evidence of intent (deed language, settlement terms, estate documents, and the history of use and maintenance).
• Exceptions and Workarounds: Some solutions require consent (a recorded release), while others require court authority (e.g., estate administration/title proceedings or a court-supervised sale where the lifetime right must be valued/handled). Choosing the wrong approach can leave you with an unmarketable title or a lawsuit for interfering with the easement holder’s rights.

Trying to “fix” a lifetime easement without counsel can backfire—especially if the easement holder is still living and using the property, or if heirs/co-owners disagree about who must pay taxes, insurance, repairs, or other carrying costs.

Get Connected with a Pennsylvania Attorney

Do not leave your legal outcome to chance. We can connect you with a pre-screened Probate attorney in Pennsylvania to review the recorded easement/lifetime-right language, the property division documents, and the estate/ownership history—and then advise whether a negotiated release, a title petition in Orphans’ Court, or another court remedy is realistic.

Find a Pennsylvania Attorney Now

Disclaimer: This article provides general information under Pennsylvania law and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change frequently. For legal advice specific to your situation, please consult with a licensed attorney.