Pennsylvania: Options When the Other Party Asks the Court Only to Sell the House | Pennsylvania Partition Actions | FastCounsel
Get Matched
PA Pennsylvania Partition Actions

Pennsylvania: Options When the Other Party Asks the Court Only to Sell the House

August 18, 2025 5 min read

Detailed Answer

Short answer: If the other side asks the court only to sell the house without setting buyout terms, you have options: you can object and ask the court to set buyout terms or an alternate remedy, negotiate a buyout before sale, request valuation and temporary orders, move for partition in kind or an accounting, or pursue settlement/mediation. Which option is best depends on whether this is a divorce/property division case or a partition action and on the court papers filed.

How Pennsylvania law frames the situation

In Pennsylvania, courts resolve disputes over family property under the equitable distribution rules found in the Divorce Code (Title 23, Chapter 35), and civil courts decide partition and forced-sale actions under local civil procedure. The Divorce Code gives courts broad discretion to divide property equitably—meaning fairly, not necessarily equally—so a request for sale alone is not final if other remedies are appropriate. See Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes, Title 23 (Domestic Relations): Chapter 35 (Disposition of Property) for the legal framework: https://www.legis.state.pa.us/cfdocs/legis/LI/consCheck.cfm?txtType=HTM&ttl=23.

Step-by-step options and practical steps

  1. Check the papers immediately and file a timely response.

    If you received a complaint or motion that asks only for a sale, you must respond within the time limits set by the court rules. Failing to respond can let the other side get a default order that may make it harder to assert buyout rights later.

  2. Ask the court for a hearing or to set terms before any sale.

    You can move for a hearing or file a written objection asking the judge to resolve whether a sale is appropriate and, if not, to set buyout terms (a price or method to calculate value). Courts often require valuation before ordering a sale or may give you a chance to buy out the other party.

  3. Request an appraisal or appointment of a neutral expert/commissioner.

    Ask the court to order a professional appraisal or appoint a master/commissioner to determine fair market value. A credible valuation supports buyout offers and protects you if the court orders sale.

  4. Pursue a buyout proposal.

    Propose a buyout price based on the agreed or court-ordered valuation. A buyout can be funded with cash, refinancing the mortgage, or installment payments with a security interest. If you need time to refinance, ask the court for a short delay or temporary exclusive possession while you complete financing.

  5. Move for partition in kind or an accounting (if applicable).

    In some non-divorce cases (co-owners, heirs), you can ask for partition in kind (divide property rather than sell) or an accounting of expenses, rents, and mortgage payments before any sale proceeds division.

  6. Ask the court to set sale mechanics and distribution rules if sale goes forward.

    If sale is unavoidable, request that the court set clear terms: listing process, minimum acceptable price, who pays ordinary costs, allocation of mortgage payoff, liens, prorations (taxes, HOA), and net-proceeds distribution method. This avoids surprise discounts or unfair distribution of costs.

  7. Seek temporary orders for occupancy, bills, and mortgage payments.

    Ask the court to allocate responsibility for mortgage, insurance, utilities, and property upkeep while litigation continues. A court can order the party who stays in the house to pay rent or mortgage contributions.

  8. Negotiate or mediate.

    Mediation or settlement talks often produce buyout terms faster and cheaper than litigation. You can propose structured buyouts, deferred payments, or sale-with-right-of-first-refusal to keep control of the process.

  9. Prepare documentation and numbers.

    Gather mortgage statements, payoff figures, tax bills, insurance, HOA dues, recent appraisals or comps, and proof of improvements or payments you made. Clear documentation improves your bargaining position and supports motions to the court.

Common buyout methods courts and parties use

  • Single lump-sum payment equal to the house’s fair market value minus mortgage and credits for each party’s contributions.
  • Refinance: one party refinances in their name, pays off the other’s share, and removes the other from the mortgage and title.
  • Installment buyout: pay the other party over time, secured by a mortgage, lien, or promissory note.
  • Offset with other assets: one spouse keeps the house and other gives up other marital assets to balance values.

Things the court will consider (and you should raise)

  • Fair market value and mortgage payoff.
  • Each party’s contributions (mortgage payments, improvements, upkeep).
  • Tax, capital gains, and transfer consequences of sale vs. buyout.
  • Ability to refinance or pay a buyout.
  • Best interests of any dependent children if occupancy affects schooling or stability.

When to get a lawyer

If the other side presses for a sale without buyout terms, or if significant equity or competing claims exist, consult a Pennsylvania attorney. A lawyer can file the right motions, seek valuations, and try to negotiate a buyout or protect your occupancy and financial interests.

Relevant Pennsylvania law and resources

Pennsylvania provides the legal framework for property division in the Divorce Code (Title 23). For the statutory framework governing disposition of marital property, see Title 23, Chapter 35: https://www.legis.state.pa.us/cfdocs/legis/LI/consCheck.cfm?txtType=HTM&ttl=23. For civil partition or forcible sale procedures, review local civil rules and consult county court rules or a local attorney because procedure varies by county and case type.

Disclaimer

This article is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. It does not create an attorney-client relationship. For legal advice specific to your situation, consult a licensed Pennsylvania attorney.

Helpful Hints

  • Respond quickly to court papers—deadlines matter.
  • Ask the court for a valuation before agreeing to any sale.
  • Collect mortgage, tax, insurance, HOA, and improvement records now.
  • Consider mediation to preserve options and reduce costs.
  • If you want to keep the house, demonstrate your ability to refinance and pay off the other party’s share.
  • If a sale proceeds, ask the court to set minimum sale terms and how costs will be shared so proceeds split is fair.
  • Keep proof of any payments you made (mortgage, taxes, repairs) to claim credit in distribution or buyout calculations.
  • Consult an attorney early if equity is substantial, liens exist, or competing creditors may claim proceeds.

The information on this site is for general informational purposes only, may be outdated, and is not legal advice; do not rely on it without consulting your own attorney.