Detailed Answer
Short answer: If an Ohio insurer stops updating you or threatens to close your claim, you should preserve written records, demand a written status or reason for closure, comply promptly with reasonable document requests, give a firm written deadline for a response, and — if the insurer does not respond or acts unfairly — file a complaint with the Ohio Department of Insurance and consider getting legal help.
Why this matters
Insurance claims can be time-sensitive. Delays, unexplained silence, or threats to close a claim can harm your ability to recover. Ohio law prohibits certain unfair claim settlement practices by insurers. See Ohio Rev. Code § 3901.22 for examples of prohibited conduct, and contact the Ohio Department of Insurance if you suspect a violation: https://insurance.ohio.gov/.
Step-by-step actions to take right away
-
Preserve and organize all communications and evidence.
Keep emails, text messages, letters, voicemails (note date/time and who you spoke with), photos, estimates, invoices, receipts, and a timeline of events. Create a single folder (physical and/or digital) labeled with claim number.
-
Request a written status and the reason for any threatened closure.
Call to ask for an update, but always follow up with a written request (email or certified letter). Ask for:
- current claim status;
- specific reasons the company says it may close the claim;
- what additional information or documents, if any, are needed to keep it open;
- a named contact and a deadline for response.
-
Respond quickly to reasonable requests for information.
Insurers are entitled to proof of loss and supporting documents. Provide what’s requested promptly if it is accurate and complete. Keep copies and proof of delivery.
-
Demand that any closure be in writing and explain your appeal options.
If the insurer threatens to close the file over the phone, demand written confirmation that specifies the closure reason and whether there is an internal appeal or reconsideration process.
-
Put a firm deadline and notify the insurer of next steps.
Send a short certified letter or email saying you will file a complaint with the Ohio Department of Insurance (or seek other remedies) if you do not get a substantive written response by a specific date (typically 10–14 days). This creates a record.
-
File a complaint with the Ohio Department of Insurance if the carrier fails to act fairly.
The Department investigates complaints about unfair claim practices and may help persuade the insurer to act. For consumer help and to file a complaint, start at the Department’s consumer pages: https://insurance.ohio.gov/
-
Consider hiring an attorney when the loss is significant or the insurer’s conduct appears unlawful.
An attorney can advise you about possible statutory claims, contract enforcement, or other remedies and can communicate with the insurer on your behalf.
Relevant Ohio law and resources
Ohio law lists unfair claim settlement practices that insurers may not engage in. For example, Ohio Rev. Code § 3901.22 addresses unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts or practices in the business of insurance. Read the statute here: http://codes.ohio.gov/orc/3901.22. If you want the state agency that regulates insurers, use the Ohio Department of Insurance for consumer guidance and complaint filing: https://insurance.ohio.gov/.
When to consider more formal action
Consider escalating if the insurer:
- fails to acknowledge or investigate your claim after reasonable notice;
- refuses to tell you why it is closing the claim in writing;
- denies the claim without explaining the reason or without a factual basis;
- pressures you to accept a low settlement or sign a release without full information;
- exhibits patterns of delay, misrepresentation, or other unfair practices.
Possible next steps include a formal complaint to the Department of Insurance, mediation or appraisal if your policy provides those options, small-claims court for smaller disputes, or hiring a private attorney for contract or other legal claims.
Helpful Hints
- Keep a call log: note date, time, person spoken to, and what was said.
- Always ask for the claim number and the name and direct contact information of your adjuster.
- Send important communications by certified mail with return receipt when you need proof of delivery.
- Do not sign a final release or settlement until you understand exactly what you are giving up.
- Take clear photos/videos of damage and save originals of all estimates and receipts.
- Read your policy’s provisions about proof of loss, deadlines, appraisal, and appeal rights.
- If you get a written denial, request a written explanation of the denial and the evidence relied upon.
- Use the Ohio Department of Insurance as a resource before spending money on litigation; the Department can investigate patterns of misconduct.