FastCounsel

Detailed Answer

Short version: If a person who would otherwise have priority refuses to sign a written renunciation, you cannot rely on that refusal informally. You should (1) ask the relative to sign a formal written renunciation that the court will accept, (2) file a petition with the probate court to be appointed personal representative and give proper notice to interested persons, and (3) if the relative continues to refuse, ask the court to resolve the dispute — which may include appointing you if the court finds the relative is unwilling, unavailable, incapacitated, or otherwise inappropriate to serve.

How renunciation normally works

Renunciation is a formal, signed statement in which a person who otherwise has a right to be appointed as personal representative gives up that right. Courts generally require a written, signed and (in many jurisdictions) notarized renunciation filed with the probate court. An oral or informal refusal is usually not enough for the court to treat the right as renounced.

Practical steps to take in Montana

1. Ask the relative to sign the proper renunciation form.

   Explain what a renunciation does (it lets someone else be appointed) and that signing limits the signing person’s duties and exposure for the estate. Many people refuse because they misunderstand the responsibilities. Offer a standard renunciation form or ask the court clerk for form guidance. The court clerk or the Montana Courts self-help pages can point you to local forms and filing procedures: Montana Courts — Self Help.

2. File your own petition to be appointed personal representative.

   If you want to serve, file a petition with the appropriate Montana district court requesting appointment. The petition must identify interested persons, state why you are entitled to appointment (for example, next in line if the other person renounces or is unavailable), and request the court’s action. The court will require notices and may schedule a hearing so interested persons can object.

3. If the relative refuses to sign, explain the consequences and document the refusal.

   Ask the relative to put the refusal in writing or sign a simple statement declining to renounce. This record can help the court understand the situation. If the relative is avoiding the process, the court may regard them as unavailable.

4. Ask the court to decide — the judge can appoint someone else.

   If the relative refuses to renounce but the court determines the relative is unwilling or not suitable to serve, the judge can appoint another qualified person. The court will consider statutory priority, the best interests of the estate and heirs, any conflicts of interest, and whether the proposed personal representative is qualified and willing.

5. If incapacity or misconduct is involved, pursue appropriate court relief.

   When the relative’s refusal stems from incapacity or if the relative is actively preventing administration, you can seek a court determination of incapacity or ask the court to remove or bypass that person. These are contested proceedings and typically require clear evidence and careful pleadings.

6. Consider a bond, indemnity or limited appointment to reassure objectors.

   Some interested persons will sign a renunciation if they understand they won’t be exposed to liability or if they can require a bond or restrict the scope of the appointment. Offer reasonable protections in writing and present them to the court if needed.

7. Get an attorney if the situation is contested or complicated.

   When relatives refuse and positions harden, a contested probate matter can become legally and factually complex. A lawyer can prepare petitions, collect evidence (such as showing the relative is unavailable or unfit), and represent you at hearings.

What the Montana courts and law expect

Montana’s probate system follows statutory appointment procedures and formal filing and notice requirements. The court looks to the statutory order of priority when appointing a personal representative and will accept formal written renunciations filed in the estate. For primary legal text and to locate the exact statutory provisions and local probate forms, check the Montana Code and the Montana courts’ self-help and forms pages:

• Montana Code Annotated (MCA) — Legislative Website
• Montana Courts — Self Help and Forms

Common outcomes

• If the relative signs a proper renunciation and it is filed, the court will move to appoint the next person in priority (which may be you) after required notice.
• If the relative refuses but is plainly unavailable or unwilling, the court may appoint you after notice and a hearing.
• If the relative refuses and a dispute arises (for example, the relative objects to your appointment), the court will resolve the dispute at a hearing considering priority, suitability, conflicts, and estate interests.

Warning: Do not act as personal representative without a court appointment. Acting without authority can create personal liability.

Disclaimer

This information is educational only and is not legal advice. It describes general Montana procedures and options but does not apply to every situation. For advice about your particular situation, consult a lawyer admitted in Montana.

Helpful Hints

• Ask the court clerk for local probate forms and sample renunciation language before preparing documents.
• Use a written, signed and notarized renunciation form — courts often require a formal signed document.
• Give clear, polite written notice to all interested persons when you file a petition; keep copies and proof of service.
• Document any conversations with the relative about renunciation and keep any written refusals or emails.
• If the relative fears liability, explain personal representatives are generally protected by estate funds and may be compensated; consider proposing a bond or indemnity to ease concerns.
• If the dispute looks likely to become contested, hire a probate attorney early — contested proceedings are time-sensitive and evidence-driven.
• Do not begin collecting assets, paying bills, or closing accounts until you have been formally appointed by the court.
• If the relative may be mentally or physically incapacitated, consider whether a guardianship or incapacity declaration may be needed — discuss this with an attorney.