Disclaimer: This is general information and not legal advice. For guidance specific to your situation, consult a Missouri-licensed attorney or a qualified vehicle appraiser.
Detailed Answer: How to get an appraisal that proves diminished value for a vehicle in Missouri
Diminished value is the loss in a vehicle’s market value that remains after repairs following a collision. To prove that loss in Missouri you will typically obtain a written appraisal that compares the vehicle’s pre-accident market value to its post-repair market value and explains the difference.
Follow these steps to get a reliable appraisal and present it to an insurer or a court:
-
Understand the three common types of diminished value:
- Immediate (inherent) diminished value: The value loss simply because a vehicle has a recorded collision history even if repairs are excellent.
- Repair-related diminished value: Loss tied to repairs that were incomplete, used non‑original parts, or otherwise reduced the vehicle’s value.
- Repair cost difference: The difference between pre‑accident market value and the vehicle’s value after repair costs are considered.
-
Gather documentation before the inspection:
- Photos of pre‑accident condition (if available) and clear photos of damage and all repaired areas.
- Repair invoices and parts receipts showing what was repaired and what parts were used.
- Vehicle maintenance records, title history, and current odometer reading.
- A vehicle history report (e.g., CARFAX) showing accident branding or damage history.
-
Choose the right appraiser:
- Pick an appraiser experienced with diminished value opinions. Look for credentials such as ASE certification, dealership or auction experience, or memberships in professional appraisal organizations.
- Ask about the appraiser’s methodology: reputable reports use a sales-comparison approach (comparing similar nearby vehicles), document market data, and explain adjustments for mileage, condition, options, and regional market trends.
- Get a written engagement that explains scope, fee, and timeline. Typical fees vary (often $100–$500), depending on vehicle complexity and report detail.
-
Inspection and appraisal report:
- The appraiser will inspect the vehicle in person when possible. Expect detailed photos, notes about structural or frame damage (if any), and review of repair invoices.
- The report should state the appraiser’s opinion of the pre-accident value, the post‑repair value, and the computed diminished value with a clear explanation of the method and data sources (market comps, auction results, private sale listings).
- Ensure the report is signed, dated, and includes contact information for the appraiser so an insurer or lawyer can verify details.
-
Present the appraisal to the insurance company or claimant:
- If you are claiming diminished value from an at‑fault driver’s insurer (third‑party claim), submit the appraisal, repair records, and vehicle history report. Insurers will often respond with a counteroffer or request more information.
- If you are pursuing first‑party diminished value (against your own insurer), check your policy for appraisal or arbitration clauses that could require a particular appraisal process. Read your contract carefully and note any deadlines for submitting a claim or invoking appraisal.
- Insurers sometimes rely on their own accepted formulae or use independent appraisers. Be prepared to negotiate or to seek appraisal arbitration if the policy provides for it.
-
If the insurer rejects the appraisal or offers too little:
- Ask for a written explanation of the insurer’s refusal or low offer. Keep careful records of all communication.
- Consider a second independent appraisal if you believe the first is incomplete.
- In Missouri you may pursue the claim in small claims court for smaller amounts or bring a civil suit for larger losses. If your insurance policy contains an appraisal or arbitration clause, you may be required to use that procedure—check your policy and talk to an attorney if needed.
-
When to involve an attorney:
- Hire a Missouri attorney experienced in auto claims if the insurer refuses to pay a reasonable diminished value, if the legal issues are complex, or if you need help navigating appraisal/arbitration procedures.
- An attorney can advise on Missouri-specific procedural rules, statutes of limitations, and strategies for presenting an appraisal in court or settlement negotiations.
Missouri-specific resources
For general insurance questions or complaints in Missouri, contact the Missouri Department of Commerce & Insurance: https://insurance.mo.gov. For Missouri statutes and legislation text, use the Missouri Revisor of Statutes: https://revisor.mo.gov. These resources can help you check policy rules, consumer protections, and any statutory deadlines that may apply.
Helpful Hints
- Order the appraisal promptly — market values and evidence (photos, dealer offers) are easier to document close to the time of repair.
- Prefer appraisers who explain their calculations and provide comparable sales data, not just a single dollar figure.
- Keep everything in writing. Save repair invoices, emails, and the appraiser’s signed report.
- Ask the appraiser whether they will testify or provide deposition support if the claim ends up in court; some will for an extra fee.
- If you plan to use the appraisal against your own insurer, read your insurance policy for an appraisal clause or deadline provisions before you submit any claim paperwork.
- Be cautious with online “instant diminished value calculators.” They can give a rough idea but won’t replace a thorough written appraisal backed by market data.
- If the vehicle’s title is branded (salvage, rebuilt), that can create a significant, often easy-to-prove, diminished value; include title history in your evidence.
If you decide you need professional help locating a qualified appraiser or a Missouri attorney who handles diminished-value claims, consider contacting the Missouri Bar referral service at https://mobar.org or searching for ASE-certified appraisers at https://www.ase.com.
Again, this information is educational and not legal advice. For a legally binding course of action, consult a Missouri-licensed attorney or an experienced vehicle appraiser.