FastCounsel

Short answer

In Massachusetts you can seek payment for diminished value (the reduction in a vehicle’s market value after an accident and repair) from the at-fault driver’s insurer or, in limited circumstances, from your own insurer. The process requires establishing the vehicle’s pre‑loss market value, the post‑repair market value, and a reasonable calculation of the difference. If an insurer refuses to pay, you can file an internal appeal, complain to the Massachusetts Division of Insurance, or pursue a civil claim (including consumer protection claims under M.G.L. c. 93A). This is a general explanation, not legal advice.

Detailed answer — step-by-step process under Massachusetts law

1) Confirm liability and file the property damage claim

Before asking for diminished value, you normally file a property damage claim with the at‑fault party’s insurer (or your own insurer if necessary). Liability should be established or sufficiently supported by the police report, witness statements, or other evidence. If fault is disputed, diminished value claims are harder to resolve until fault is clear.

2) Document the vehicle’s pre‑accident value

Gather evidence of the vehicle’s market value immediately before the crash. Useful items include:

• Comparable listings (NADA, Kelley Blue Book, local classifieds)
• Dealer trade‑in or retail price guides
• Recent purchase invoices or trade paperwork if you bought the car recently

3) Complete repairs and collect repair documentation

Get written repair estimates, completed repair invoices, and photos of both the damage and the finished repairs. Keep all receipts for parts and labor. A high‑quality repair job does not necessarily eliminate inherent diminished value, so documentation is essential.

4) Obtain a diminished value appraisal or written opinion of market loss

Hire a qualified appraiser who regularly performs diminished value reports in your market. The appraiser should calculate the vehicle’s market value before the loss, market value after repair, and the resulting diminished value. Some appraisers use comparable sales, auction results, and local market data.

5) Present a written demand to the at‑fault insurer

Send a demand packet that includes:

• Claim/accident information and the police report
• Repair invoices and photos
• Pre‑ and post‑loss value evidence
• The independent diminished value appraisal
• A clear dollar demand with deadline for response

6) Negotiate or escalate

The insurer may accept the demand, make a counteroffer, or deny the claim. If they deny or offer less than expected, you can:

• Ask for a written explanation of the denial or basis for a low offer.
• Provide additional comparables or a second appraisal.
• File a complaint with the Massachusetts Division of Insurance (see links below).
• Consider a demand letter under M.G.L. c. 93A for unfair or deceptive practices if the insurer’s conduct is unreasonable.
• File in small claims or civil court if the amount falls within the court’s jurisdictional limits.

Legal background and remedies

Massachusetts does not have a single statutory provision that specifically governs diminished value payments. However, two important statutory frameworks apply to insurer conduct:

• Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 176D — Unfair practices in the business of insurance: https://malegislature.gov/Laws/GeneralLaws/PartI/TitleXX/Chapter176D
• Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 93A — Consumer protection (unfair or deceptive acts or practices): https://malegislature.gov/Laws/GeneralLaws/PartI/TitleXVI/Chapter93A

These statutes allow insureds or claimants to challenge unreasonable denials, bad faith, or deceptive settlement tactics. You can also file a complaint with the Massachusetts Division of Insurance: https://www.mass.gov/orgs/division-of-insurance and find consumer complaint instructions at https://www.mass.gov/how-to/file-a-complaint-with-the-division-of-insurance

Timing and statute of limitations

Act promptly. Insurance companies expect timely notice and proof. For lawsuits, Massachusetts civil statute of limitations for property damage claims is generally three years from the date of damage (M.G.L. c. 260, §2). If you plan a consumer protection claim under Chapter 93A, different rules and pre‑suit requirements (demand letters) can apply. Consult counsel if you approach these time periods.

When to consider an attorney

Consider consulting an attorney if:

• Liability is disputed and the diminished value depends on establishing fault.
• The insurer refuses reasonable proof without explanation or engages in conduct that may violate M.G.L. c. 176D or c. 93A.
• The claimed amount is significant and negotiation stalls.

An attorney can evaluate whether a Chapter 93A demand is appropriate and can calculate potential statutory damages and attorney’s fees where permitted by law.

Evidence you should gather

• Police report and any dashcam or witness statements
• High‑resolution photos of damage before repairs and of completed repairs
• Repair estimates and final invoices
• Pre‑accident valuation sources (KBB, NADA, local listings)
• Diminished value appraisal from an independent appraiser
• Correspondence with insurers (emails, letters, recorded dates of phone calls)

Common insurer responses and how to react

Insurers commonly:

• Pay the cost to repair the vehicle but deny inherent diminished value — provide your appraisal and comparables if this happens.
• Offer a modest settlement — ask for the insurer’s valuation method and offer supporting evidence.
• Request negotiations be limited until liability is resolved — prioritize establishing liability first.

Helpful Hints

• Start documentation immediately: photographs and pre‑loss value evidence are most credible when gathered right after the accident.
• Use a reputable diminished value appraiser — check references and sample reports before paying for an appraisal.
• Keep repair work high quality and documented; poor repairs may create repair‑related diminished value that strengthens your claim.
• If you receive a low offer, request written reasoning and compare their approach to your appraisal’s methodology.
• Before filing a Chapter 93A demand, read the statute and consider a legal consultation — Chapter 93A can carry additional damages and fee awards but also has procedural requirements: https://malegislature.gov/Laws/GeneralLaws/PartI/TitleXVI/Chapter93A
• If you suspect bad faith insurance practices, contact the Massachusetts Division of Insurance for guidance: https://www.mass.gov/orgs/division-of-insurance