What a Lien on a Personal Injury Settlement Means and How It Can Affect Your Recovery
Disclaimer: This is educational information only and is not legal advice. For guidance specific to your case, consult a licensed Maryland attorney.
Detailed Answer
What is a lien? A lien is a legal claim by a person or organization against money you receive from a third party — in this context, money you recover in a personal injury settlement or judgment. When an entity has a valid lien, it can require that portion of your settlement be paid to it to reimburse costs it paid on your behalf (commonly medical bills or government benefits paid for treatment).
Common types of liens that may affect a Maryland personal injury recovery
- Health insurer subrogation or reimbursement claims: If a private health insurer or an ERISA plan paid medical bills for injuries, the plan may have a contractual right to be reimbursed from your settlement. These claims often arise by contract and plan terms, and sometimes by equitable subrogation.
- Medicare conditional payment and recovery: If Medicare paid for treatment related to your injury, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) can seek repayment from your settlement. CMS publishes guidance on how to request a conditional payment amount and the process to resolve Medicare’s claim. See Medicare’s recovery guidance: https://www.cms.gov/Medicare/Coordination-of-Benefits-and-Recovery/Medicare-Secondary-Payer
- Medicaid and state liens or claims: If Maryland Medicaid paid for care, Maryland may seek reimbursement. State Medicaid programs also have estate recovery rules for certain deceased beneficiaries. For state law and agency information, see the Maryland Department of Health: https://health.maryland.gov/ and the Maryland Code (searchable): https://mgaleg.maryland.gov/mgawebsite/Laws/Code
- Hospital or provider liens: Some jurisdictions allow hospitals or health providers to file liens against settlement proceeds. Whether and how hospitals can assert such liens depends on state law and contracts with the patient.
- Workers’ compensation lien: If you received workers’ compensation benefits for the injury, the workers’ compensation insurer usually has a statutory right to recover from any third-party settlement.
- Attorney’s charging lien/retainer lien: Your lawyer may have a lien or right to take fees and costs from the settlement under Maryland rules or court practice. That claim generally attaches to the recovery before you receive funds.
How a lien can affect the amount you actually receive
- Liens reduce your net recovery. The lienholder can demand payment out of the settlement proceeds, so a lien reduces the money left to pay your attorney, cover non-medical damages, or pay future needs.
- Priority matters. Multiple lienholders and your attorney’s fee entitlement will compete for the settlement funds. Which claims get paid first depends on the type of lien and applicable law or contract.
- Timing and settlement delay. Lienholders (especially Medicare) often require documentation and approval to determine the amount they will accept. That process can delay distribution of settlement funds.
- Potential reduction or negotiation. Many liens are negotiable. Insurers, providers, and state agencies sometimes accept less than the full billed amount. Your attorney can negotiate reductions or demand proof that charges were reasonable and actually for treatment of the injury at issue.
Maryland-specific considerations
Maryland follows general principles about subrogation and reimbursement claims, and state agencies have established procedures for recovery of public benefits. Because statutes, regulations, and agency practices affect how a lien is asserted and resolved, it helps to review Maryland authorities or seek a Maryland attorney’s advice. You can look up Maryland statutes and related law at the Maryland General Assembly site: https://mgaleg.maryland.gov/mgawebsite/Laws/Code and Maryland court resources at the Maryland Judiciary: https://www.mdcourts.gov/.
Typical steps to handle a lien on a personal injury settlement
- Identify every possible lien or reimbursement claim early. Ask insurers, medical providers, and public benefit programs what claims they have.
- Request written itemizations and legal basis. Do not accept a bare demand — require a written statement of the lien amount and supporting documents showing the charges relate to the injury.
- Evaluate who has priority. Your lawyer (or you) should determine whether claims are contractual, statutory, or equitable and which will be paid first.
- Negotiate reductions where possible. Many providers settle for a lower amount, especially if full payment is unlikely or the billed amount exceeds reasonable value.
- Resolve Medicare conditional payments before closing a settlement. CMS has a formal process to request a conditional payment amount and to contest it when appropriate: https://www.cms.gov/Medicare/Coordination-of-Benefits-and-Recovery/Medicare-Secondary-Payer
- If a lien is disputed, raise the dispute before funds disburse. Do not distribute settlement funds until liens are resolved or adequate protections (escrow, interpleader, or court approval) are in place.
Common outcomes
- You could pay a portion or all of a lien out of your settlement and receive a smaller net payment.
- Negotiation may significantly reduce amounts owed, increasing what you keep.
- Unresolved liens can produce lawsuits after settlement, so resolving or securing disputed claims before distribution is critical.
Helpful Hints
- Start early. Identify liens as soon as possible after the injury so you have time to request payor documentation and negotiate.
- Ask for itemized bills and proof the care related to the injury claimed in your case.
- Keep records. Save all medical records, bills, insurer explanations of benefits (EOBs), and correspondence related to payments and liens.
- Check private insurer plan rules. ERISA plans have strict procedures and deadlines for asserting subrogation or reimbursement rights.
- Don’t ignore Medicare or Medicaid. Failure to address federal or state recovery claims can create large obligations later; use CMS processes for conditional payment workups and resolution: https://www.cms.gov/Medicare/Coordination-of-Benefits-and-Recovery/Medicare-Secondary-Payer
- Consider setting aside funds. If a lien is disputed, ask the court or settling parties to place money in escrow or use an interpleader until the claim resolves.
- Get legal help. A Maryland personal injury attorney can evaluate lien validity, negotiate reductions, and protect your net recovery. If you cannot afford a lawyer, look for Maryland legal aid resources and court self-help pages: https://www.mdcourts.gov/selfhelp
- Be cautious about signing releases. A full release without resolving lien claims may leave you responsible later for reimbursement demands.