The Short Answer

In Florida, correcting a mistaken life insurance payout usually depends on why the wrong person was paid and whether the insurer had notice of a competing claim before it paid. In many cases, the insurer may be legally discharged after paying the person designated in the policy, so the practical remedy can shift to a claim against the recipient (or litigation to impose a constructive trust) rather than “making the insurer pay twice.”

What Florida Law Says

Life insurance proceeds generally go to the beneficiary designated in the policy, and Florida law provides significant protection to insurers who pay according to the policy terms. That means a “mistaken distribution” can be hard to unwind unless there is a clear legal basis (for example, the insurer paid after receiving written notice of a competing claim, the beneficiary designation was invalid due to wrongdoing, or the beneficiary is legally disqualified).

The Statute

The primary law governing insurer discharge after payment is Fla. Stat. § 627.423.

This statute establishes that when life insurance proceeds become payable and the insurer pays in accordance with the policy, that payment generally fully discharges the insurer from further claims—unless the insurer received written notice at its home office before payment that someone else claimed entitlement.

Florida also has a specific rule that a beneficiary who unlawfully and intentionally kills the insured is treated as having predeceased the insured for purposes of life insurance benefits. See Fla. Stat. § 732.802.

If you’re trying to understand whether life insurance proceeds should have avoided probate (or when they don’t), you may find this helpful: Do Life Insurance Proceeds Avoid Probate in Florida If There’s a Named Beneficiary?

Why You Should Speak with an Attorney

While the statutes provide the general framework, fixing a wrong payout is rarely simple because the “right” remedy depends on facts that insurers and courts treat very differently:

• Strict notice and timing issues: Under Fla. Stat. § 627.423, whether the insurer received proper written notice before it paid can determine if the insurer is discharged or still exposed.
• Burden of proof: If your claim is that the beneficiary designation was invalid (for example, due to undue influence, fraud, or lack of capacity), you typically need strong documentation and witness evidence—often requiring subpoenas and litigation strategy.
• Exceptions and disqualifications: If the recipient is legally disqualified (such as under Florida’s “killer” rule in Fla. Stat. § 732.802), the analysis can shift quickly to who becomes entitled instead—and whether the insurer had notice.

Just as important, life insurance disputes often involve multiple legal tracks (probate, trust, and civil claims like unjust enrichment/constructive trust). Choosing the wrong approach can delay recovery or result in a dismissal that’s difficult to fix later.

Get Connected with a Florida Attorney

Do not leave your legal outcome to chance. We can connect you with a pre-screened Probate attorney in Florida to discuss your specific facts and options.

Find a Florida Attorney Now

Disclaimer: This article provides general information under Florida law and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws change frequently. For legal advice specific to your situation, please consult with a licensed attorney.