Challenging Transfers Made Under a Power of Attorney in Colorado | Colorado Estate Planning | FastCounsel
CO Colorado

Challenging Transfers Made Under a Power of Attorney in Colorado

Can transfers made under a power of attorney be challenged in Colorado?

This FAQ-style article explains how Colorado law treats transfers made using a power of attorney (POA), common legal grounds to challenge those transfers, and practical steps you can take if you suspect your grandfather lacked capacity when the transactions occurred. This is educational information only and not legal advice.

Detailed answer — how Colorado law approaches POA transfers

Colorado recognizes written powers of attorney under the Colorado Uniform Power of Attorney Act (generally codified in the Colorado Revised Statutes, Title 15). A durable power of attorney can authorize an agent to manage finances and to transfer property on behalf of the principal. But transfers made by an agent are not immune from challenge.

You can challenge a transfer if you can show that, at the time the POA was executed or when the transfer was made, the principal (here, your grandfather) lacked the mental capacity necessary to create or authorize the POA; or if the agent used undue influence, fraud, or committed self-dealing or other breaches of fiduciary duty. Colorado law also treats forgery, a revoked or expired POA, or transfers that violate the agent’s written authority as grounds for reversal.

Key legal themes under Colorado law:

  • Capacity at the time of signing or transfer. The principal must have had sufficient mental capacity to understand the nature and effect of the power of attorney and the consequences of the transactions.
  • Undue influence and fraud. If someone coerced or manipulated the principal into signing a POA or into making transfers, a court may set those transactions aside.
  • Scope and validity of the POA. The POA must have been valid (properly signed, witnessed/notarized if required) and the transfers must fall within the powers granted to the agent.
  • Breach of fiduciary duty. Agents owe duties to their principals; self-dealing or using the principal’s assets for personal benefit can give rise to civil claims.

For the statute governing powers of attorney in Colorado, consult the Colorado Revised Statutes (Title 15) and the Colorado Uniform Power of Attorney Act at the Colorado General Assembly site: https://leg.colorado.gov/colorado-revised-statutes. For information about guardianship and conservatorship procedures (when an emergency appointment may be needed), see the Colorado Judicial Branch self-help pages: https://www.courts.state.co.us/Self_Help/Guardianship/Index.cfm.

Common legal claims used to undo transfers

  • Lack of capacity (challenge the validity of the POA or the transaction).
  • Undue influence or coercion (prove someone exerted improper pressure).
  • Fraud or forgery (documents not genuine or were procured by deceit).
  • Breach of fiduciary duty or self-dealing (agent put their interests above the principal’s).
  • Violation of the POA’s terms (agent acted beyond authority).

Who decides and what court handles it?

Disputes over POAs and related transfers are usually handled in Colorado district court. If the principal is deceased, the matter may arise in a probate case (estate administration). If the principal is alive but incapacitated, interested persons can seek relief through emergency temporary orders or by petitioning for guardianship/conservatorship.

How to proceed if you suspect lack of capacity

If you suspect your grandfather lacked capacity when the POA was signed or when transfers were made, act promptly. Evidence deteriorates and banks or third parties may be unable or unwilling to reverse transfers without a court order.

  1. Preserve documents and records. Collect copies of the POA, deeds, bank statements, transfer documents, emails, text messages, and any healthcare or medical records that relate to cognitive status.
  2. Get medical records and evaluations. Medical records and contemporaneous notes from doctors or care providers can show cognitive decline. A qualified medical professional’s retrospective or current evaluation may be necessary to prove incapacity.
  3. Identify witnesses. Note who was present when the POA was signed or when transfers occurred. Witness statements and notary evidence can be critical.
  4. Freeze or restrict further transfers when possible. If you can show immediate risk, a court can issue temporary restraints or an emergency guardianship/conservatorship order. Some banks will freeze accounts if you present a court order.
  5. Consider alternative claims. In addition to attacking the POA, you might have claims for conversion, unjust enrichment, constructive trust, or breach of fiduciary duty to recover assets improperly transferred.
  6. Talk to an attorney experienced in Colorado elder law/probate litigation. An attorney can evaluate evidence, advise on filing a petition in district court, and suggest remedies such as rescission of transfers or imposing a constructive trust.

If you need procedural guidance on guardianship and conservatorship petitions, see the Colorado Judicial Branch self-help resources: https://www.courts.state.co.us/Self_Help/Guardianship/Index.cfm.

Practical timeline and urgency

There is no single Colorado statute-of-limitations answer that fits every situation. How fast you must act depends on the type of claim (e.g., contesting a POA, a civil fraud claim, or seeking to set aside a deed after death). Because delays can harm the chance to recover assets or to get emergency relief, act quickly to preserve evidence and seek legal advice.

What you can reasonably expect a court to consider

Courts will review the totality of the evidence, including:

  • Medical records and expert testimony about cognitive function;
  • Whether the principal understood the nature and consequences of the POA or the transfers;
  • Whether the agent had a conflict of interest or benefitted personally;
  • Whether the POA was executed according to law (signatures, witnesses, notarization if required); and
  • Whether third parties (banks, title companies) acted in good faith.

Helpful hints

  • Keep calm and document everything. Create a timeline of events with dates, documents, and contacts.
  • Secure originals whenever possible: original POA documents, original deeds, and bank statements carry more weight than copies.
  • Ask medical providers for copies of cognitive assessments and contemporaneous notes; these can be decisive.
  • Talk to banks and title companies early. They sometimes place temporary holds pending resolution or require a court order to release funds.
  • Consider mediation if all parties are willing. Some disputes resolve faster and cheaper out of court, but mediation is inappropriate if the principal is actively being harmed.
  • If you suspect criminal conduct (forgery, theft), you can contact local law enforcement—but criminal investigations run on a different track than civil recovery.
  • Act quickly. Evidence and witnesses become harder to find over time; statutes of limitation may bar some claims.

Disclaimer: This article is educational only and does not constitute legal advice, legal representation, or an attorney-client relationship. Laws change and every situation is different. To protect your rights and deadlines, consult a licensed Colorado attorney who can evaluate your specific facts and represent you in court if needed.

The information on this site is for general informational purposes only, may be outdated, and is not legal advice; do not rely on it without consulting your own attorney.