Detailed Answer
When an insurance company tells you its settlement offer is “final,” treat that statement as a negotiation position, not an absolute bar. Under Arizona law, insurers must follow the insurance code and fair claims practices (see Arizona Revised Statutes, Title 20: https://www.azleg.state.az.us/arsDetail/?title=20). You have options to challenge, document, or escalate the matter. The following plain-language steps explain what to do and why each step matters.
-
Get the offer and the insurer’s reasoning in writing.
Ask the insurer to put the offer and the basis for it in writing immediately. A written offer shows what the company believes it owes and why (policy provisions, depreciation, estimate amounts). Keep all emails, letters, estimate attachments, and voicemail records. Written documentation helps you, your appraiser, or an attorney evaluate the offer.
-
Compare the offer to your documented losses.
Collect the evidence that proves your loss: repair estimates, replacement quotes, receipts, medical records (for injury claims), police reports, photos, and videos. Compare those totals to the insurer’s offer line by line. Note differences like missing items, low labor rates, or failure to account for diminished value or out-of-pocket expenses.
-
Use policy dispute processes first (appraisal, mediation, or arbitration).
Many insurance policies include an appraisal clause (often for property claims) or an arbitration/mediation clause. These clauses provide contract-based ways to resolve valuation disputes without immediate litigation. Check your policy and ask the insurer in writing whether it will agree to appraisal or an alternative dispute resolution process.
-
Get independent estimates or expert reports.
Hire a reputable contractor, independent appraiser, or medical examiner to produce a written estimate or report. A second professional opinion often rebuts a low insurer estimate and strengthens any demand you make.
-
Send a focused demand letter.
Prepare a concise written demand that states: the policy number and claim number; the facts of loss; the total you seek; the attachments that support your amount; and a reasonable deadline (for example, 14 or 21 days) for a better response. Keep the tone factual and avoid emotional language. A clear demand puts the insurer on formal notice that you dispute the offer.
-
File a complaint with Arizona’s insurance regulator.
If the insurer refuses to engage or you suspect unfair claims handling, file a consumer complaint with the Arizona Department of Insurance & Financial Institutions (DIFI): https://difi.az.gov. The regulator can investigate whether the company followed Arizona insurance law and may contact the company on your behalf.
-
Consider whether a bad-faith or breach claim may apply.
Arizona recognizes that insurers must act reasonably in handling claims. If an insurer purposely or recklessly denies, delays, or undervalues a valid claim without a reasonable basis, you may have a contract claim and potentially a tort claim against the insurer for wrongful claim handling. These are fact-specific and often require legal analysis. Review the insurance code (Title 20) for civil remedies and procedures: Arizona Revised Statutes – Title 20.
-
Watch the time limits.
Claims and lawsuits in Arizona are subject to statutes of limitation and contractual notice deadlines. Civil claim deadlines are found in Arizona law (Title 12): https://www.azleg.state.az.us/arsDetail/?title=12. Don’t miss deadlines for filing suit or invoking policy dispute procedures—missing a deadline can permanently bar recovery.
-
Decide whether to hire an attorney.
If the insurer’s “final” offer is far below your documented losses, or if the insurer refuses appraisal/mediation and you suspect bad faith, consult a lawyer who handles insurance claims. An attorney can evaluate damages, explain potential remedies (including litigation), and, where appropriate, send a demand that often prompts a better settlement. For personal injury, property damage, or first-party claims, attorneys typically explain fee options during the consult.
-
Evaluate cost vs. benefit before litigating.
Lawsuits cost time and money. Before filing suit, run a cost-benefit analysis: likely recovery vs. legal fees, court costs, and time. Sometimes mediation after filing yields an acceptable settlement without a full trial.
Sample short demand outline (what to include)
- Claim/policy numbers and your contact information
- Short statement of facts (what happened and when)
- Itemized damages with supporting documents attached
- Reference to applicable policy provisions (coverage, appraisal clause)
- Requested amount and a clear deadline for response
- Notice that you will pursue appraisal, regulatory complaint, or litigation if not resolved
Helpful Hints
- Do not accept a check or sign a release until you are clear it fully covers your losses. Releases often bar further claims.
- Keep a chronological file of every conversation, email, and document related to your claim.
- Ask for itemized explanations if the insurer reduces payments for depreciation, wear-and-tear, or prior damage.
- Use photos and videos to document damage and the repair process.
- For property claims, ask whether your policy covers additional living expenses (loss of use) if displacement occurred.
- If the insurer relies on its chosen repair shop or vendor, get an independent estimate to compare scope and price.
- Before paying a contractor, verify licensing, insurance, and get a written scope of work and payment schedule.
- When in doubt about bad faith or large-dollar disputes, get a consultation with an attorney experienced in insurance claims—many offer a free or low-cost initial review.
Where to get more help: Review the Arizona insurance laws (Title 20) at the Arizona Legislature site: https://www.azleg.state.az.us/arsDetail/?title=20. For consumer assistance or to file a complaint, contact the Arizona Department of Insurance & Financial Institutions: https://difi.az.gov. For information on civil filing deadlines and procedures, see Arizona Revised Statutes, Title 12: https://www.azleg.state.az.us/arsDetail/?title=12.