Virginia: Can a Co-Heir Be Required to Reimburse an Appraisal Before an Estate Buyout?

Detailed Answer

Short answer: Maybe — but only if you have a contract, an enforceable agreement, a probate-authorized expense allocation, or a court order that requires the co-heir to pay. Otherwise you generally cannot unilaterally force reimbursement; you must negotiate, secure agreement, or ask a court to decide who pays.

Why: In Virginia, co-heirs (or co-owners) share rights in estate property, but the rules about who pays for what depend on the legal relationship and any existing agreements. Key scenarios:

Estate administration with a personal representative: If the property is part of an estate being administered in probate, the personal representative has duty to manage, preserve, and value estate assets. Appraisal costs properly incurred for estate administration are typically paid from estate funds as an administrative expense, subject to oversight by the probate court. See Virginia probate law at the Title 64.2 code overview: Va. Code Title 64.2. If the personal representative improperly pays an appraisal out of his or her own pocket, the estate (and therefore heirs) should be charged properly and the personal representative must account to the court.
Heir-initiated appraisal for a private buyout: If one co-heir orders an appraisal to support a buyout (for example, that heir wants to buy out the other heir’s interest), the party who ordered the appraisal will generally bear the cost unless the co-heirs agree otherwise. You can ask the co-heir to reimburse you as a condition of closing the buyout, and that can be enforceable if the other party agrees in writing. Without agreement, you cannot compel reimbursement simply by withholding a deed if the buyout closes under other terms;
Agreements and written terms: A written buyout agreement or a written agreement among heirs that allocates appraisal or valuation costs is enforceable as a contract. If the co-heir signed a document promising to share or reimburse appraisal expenses, you can enforce that promise in court;
Partition or accounting actions: If heirs cannot agree, you can ask a Virginia court to resolve ownership and expenses. In a partition action or a petition for accounting in probate, the court can allocate costs (including appraisal fees) equitably among co-owners or require contribution where one party paid a necessary expense that benefited others. See general civil and probate authority under Virginia law: Va. Code Title 8.01 (Civil Remedies and Procedure) and Va. Code Title 64.2 (Wills, Decedents, Guardians, and Trustees).

Practical implications and routes you can take:

Check for any written agreement or probate instructions. If the estate is in probate, review the court filings and ask the personal representative where appraisal fees are charged. If there is a buyout agreement, check its cost allocation clause.
Negotiate first. Offer to split the appraisal fee, or suggest placing the appraisal payment into escrow and crediting it at closing. Many disputes about small sums resolve faster with negotiation than litigation.
Make reimbursement a condition of closing. If you are the seller or buyer in the buyout, you can make reimbursement a condition in the purchase/buyout contract. A signed contract gives you leverage and an enforceable path to recovery if the other party breaches.
Use escrow or a title company. If you want a practical way to ensure payment, put the funds or documents in escrow conditioned on reimbursement or a written settlement of the appraisal fee.
File a court petition if necessary. If negotiation fails and the amount is significant, you can ask the circuit court in Virginia to decide (either in a probate accounting or a partition action). The court can order contribution, require an accounting, or allocate fees equitably. Bringing a court action has costs and takes time, so weigh the amount at issue against legal fees.
Preserve documentation. Keep the appraisal invoice, engagement letter, proof of payment, any communications about payment, the will or probate papers, and any signed buyout proposals.

Hypothetical example to illustrate:

Mary and Tom inherit a house as co-heirs. Mary hires a certified appraiser ($900) to value the house because she plans to buy Tom out. If Tom agrees in writing that appraisal costs will be split, Mary can demand reimbursement at closing. If Tom refuses and there is no agreement, Mary can either (a) cover the cost herself, (b) insist on reimbursement as a term of sale and risk delaying the closing if Tom won’t sign, or (c) file a petition in the probate or circuit court seeking contribution or asking the court to resolve the buyout and allocation of costs.

When a court is likely to require contribution

Court-ordered contribution is more likely when the appraisal was necessary for protecting the estate or for an equitable sale/buyout and when the non-paying co-heir derived or is about to derive benefit from the appraisal (for example, if the appraisal facilitated a buyout at a price that benefits both parties). Courts aim to allocate necessary administrative expenses fairly among those who benefit.

Links to Virginia law resources

Bottom line: You can require reimbursement only if you have an enforceable agreement, are acting through the probate process (so the court or personal representative can allocate costs), or obtain a court order. Otherwise, the practical remedy is negotiation, escrow arrangements, or filing a court action to seek contribution.

Disclaimer: This is general information about Virginia law and is not legal advice. For tailored advice about your situation and help drafting an agreement or filing a petition, consult a Virginia attorney familiar with probate, real estate, and partition matters.

Helpful Hints

Get any agreement about appraisal costs in writing before paying anything.
If the estate is in probate, ask the personal representative to pay the appraisal from estate funds and itemize it in the accounting.
Consider a neutral appraiser selected by both heirs to reduce disputes about value and cost allocation.
Use escrow instructions or a buyout agreement that clearly states who pays the appraisal and how it will be credited at closing.
Preserve all receipts, engagement letters, emails, and texts showing who requested and paid for the appraisal.
If negotiation fails and the cost is substantial, speak with a Virginia lawyer about filing for a court accounting or a partition action.
Ask an attorney whether small-claims court or a demand letter from counsel makes sense before filing a longer, costlier action.

FastCounsel