FastCounsel

Disclaimer: This is educational information only and not legal advice. For guidance about your specific situation, consult a licensed New York attorney.

Detailed Answer — How to prove you are your father’s child for inheritance in New York when his name isn’t on your birth certificate

When a person dies without leaving a will, New York’s intestacy rules determine who inherits. Those rules generally give priority to a surviving spouse and children. To inherit as a child, you must prove you are the decedent’s child (a process often called establishing filiation or paternity). A missing father’s name on your birth certificate does not by itself prevent inheritance; it just means you must use other evidence or legal procedures to show you are his child.

Where the law treats intestate heirs

New York’s intestacy rules are in the Estates, Powers & Trusts Law (EPTL). The law governs how property passes if there is no valid will. (See EPTL — for example: EPTL §4-1.1 (intestate distribution).)

Common legal routes to prove paternity / filiation

1. Voluntary Acknowledgment (if the father is alive and willing)

   If the father is alive, he can sign a written acknowledgment of paternity or otherwise cooperate (for example, by signing an affidavit or a sworn statement). That can be strong evidence and can be filed in court or with the estate/Surrogate’s Court.

2. Family Court paternity or legitimation proceeding

   If the father is alive and will not voluntarily acknowledge paternity, you can bring a paternity or legitimation petition in Family Court or, in some situations, a similar action in Supreme Court. The court can order genetic testing or issue an order declaring you the child.

3. Surrogate’s Court filiation / heirship proceeding (common when the father is deceased)

   If the decedent has died, you typically pursue the matter in the Surrogate’s Court that is handling the estate. You (or the estate’s personal representative) can file a petition asking the court to declare you an heir. Surrogate’s Courts accept multiple types of evidence — see the evidence list below.

   Surrogate’s Court procedures and forms are available from New York’s Unified Court System: New York Surrogate’s Courts.

4. Genetic (DNA) testing

   DNA testing is often the most direct way to prove a biological relationship. If the father is deceased, courts will permit testing of the decedent’s remains (if available) or testing of close relatives (siblings, parents, grandchildren, or known children) to establish a genetic link by comparison. A court can order testing and weigh the results as evidence of filiation.

5. Documentary and testimonial evidence

   Court will also consider documents and sworn statements: baptismal records, medical records (showing paternity acknowledgments or father listed), school or government records, affidavits from relatives or family friends, correspondence in which the decedent admits paternity, checks or other proof of financial support, photographs, and other evidence showing a parent-child relationship.

How the Surrogate’s Court usually handles these cases

If someone dies and an estate is opened, the person claiming to be a child must petition the Surrogate’s Court for recognition as an heir or for appointment as a distributee. The court will look at the totality of evidence and may:

• order genetic testing;
• accept signed acknowledgments, affidavits, or other evidence;
• weigh documentary proof and witness testimony; and
• enter an order declaring filiation if the evidence satisfies the court.

Evidence you should collect now

• Any copy of your birth certificate and any other vital records.
• Records that list the father (medical records, school forms, baptismal records, Social Security records).
• Letters, emails, social media messages, or cards in which the decedent refers to you as his child.
• Financial records showing the decedent supported you (bank transfers, checks, paid bills, insurance beneficiary changes).
• Affidavits from relatives, family friends, doctors, or others who knew the family and can attest to the relationship.
• Names and contact information for potential DNA comparators (the decedent’s parents, siblings, other children, or grandchildren).

Practical steps to take

1. Preserve all documents and communications that could show a parent-child relationship.
2. Contact the Surrogate’s Court in the county where the decedent lived or where the estate was opened. See: New York Surrogate’s Courts.
3. If the father is living and cooperative, ask him to sign a written acknowledgment or affidavit and, if appropriate, to appear in court or Family Court to confirm paternity.
4. If the father is deceased or uncooperative, be prepared to request DNA testing (through the court) using the decedent’s remains or close relatives as comparators.
5. Consider hiring an attorney who handles estates and probate litigation to file the appropriate petition and represent you in court. If cost is a concern, ask the courthouse about fee waivers or legal aid resources.

Timing and deadlines

There is no single universal deadline for filing to be recognized as an heir; timing depends on when the estate opens and what actions other heirs or the estate representative take. If an estate is already opened, act quickly: the court and the estate’s representative will normally list known heirs and distribute assets after claims are resolved. If you wait too long to assert your claim, it may complicate recovery of estate property. Speak to counsel promptly to protect your rights.

Costs and likely outcomes

Expect court filing fees and possible costs for DNA testing and attorney’s fees. If you can present DNA evidence or strong documentary proof, the Surrogate’s Court frequently recognizes filiation and awards intestate shares to eligible children. Without direct DNA or an admission, courts will weigh the total evidence — affidavits and circumstantial proof can be persuasive, but the outcome depends on the case facts and the quality of evidence.

Helpful official resources

• New York State Department of Health — Vital Records (birth certificate information and procedures to obtain or amend records): https://www.health.ny.gov/vital_records/
• New York Surrogate’s Courts information and local contact details: https://www.nycourts.gov/courts/surrogates/
• New York Estates, Powers & Trusts Law (example intestacy provision): EPTL §4-1.1

Helpful Hints

• Start gathering evidence now — documents and witness names are easier to get sooner.
• DNA is often decisive. If you can get court-ordered testing of the decedent’s remains or close relatives, do it.
• Even without DNA, clear, consistent documentary evidence and sworn statements can succeed—compile school records, medical files, letters, and photos that link you to the decedent.
• If the father is alive and helpful, get an affidavit or signed acknowledgment — that can dramatically simplify the process.
• Contact the Surrogate’s Court in the county where the estate is or will be opened. Ask the clerk what forms or petitions are needed to assert heirship.
• Because probate and filiation rules are procedural and fact‑sensitive, consult a New York probate/estate attorney early. If you cannot afford one, search for legal aid or pro bono programs in your area.
• Preserve any tissue, hairbrushes, toothbrushes, or personal items that might provide DNA from the decedent — but consult an attorney before conducting informal tests, since courts prefer chain-of-custody and court-authorized testing.

If you want, provide the county where the decedent lived or where the estate was opened, and I can outline the next procedural steps for that specific Surrogate’s Court and list likely forms and contacts.