FastCounsel

Detailed answer — how a will suspected of forgery is challenged in Utah

When you believe a will is forged, the process in Utah usually follows these broad stages: (1) determine whether you have standing to challenge the will; (2) preserve evidence and act quickly to protect assets; (3) file a challenge in probate court (or object to probate); and (4) prove forgery or related defects at a hearing or trial. Below are the practical legal steps and the types of evidence courts consider.

1. Who may challenge the will?

Generally, any “interested person” can contest a will. That typically includes beneficiaries named in an earlier will, heirs who would inherit under intestacy, a surviving spouse, or a creditor with a proper interest. If you are not sure whether you qualify, ask the probate clerk or an attorney. Utah’s probate statutes and court rules govern who may appear and how contests proceed; see Utah Code overview at the Utah Legislature website for the probate code: https://le.utah.gov/xcode/, and Utah Courts probate resources at: https://www.utcourts.gov/howto/probate/.

2. Immediate protective steps

• Locate and preserve the original will if possible. The original is typically the key piece of evidence.
• If the will has been filed for probate, obtain certified copies from the probate clerk.
• Preserve other evidence: notebooks, communications (emails/texts), bank records, physician notes, witness names, and any documents showing past signature samples.
• Notify the probate court clerk promptly that you intend to contest (some courts provide forms or instructions for filing objections).
• If assets may be distributed immediately, ask the court or move to halt distribution (temporary restraining order or a request the court not to distribute until contest resolved).

3. How to formally challenge the will

There are two common procedural routes:

1. Object when the will is offered for probate. When a will is filed for admission to probate, interested parties often have a window to object before or shortly after admission. If you object before the court admits the will, the court will typically hold a hearing on validity.
2. File a separate contest action. If the will has already been admitted, you may file a petition to revoke probate or an action in the probate court asking the court to set aside the will for forgery or other defects.

Because timing matters and procedures vary, contact the probate clerk in the county where the decedent died or where the will was filed, or consult a probate attorney. Utah Courts provide forms and guidance on probate procedures: https://www.utcourts.gov/howto/probate/.

4. Grounds you can assert

Forgery is one ground, but a challenger can also claim the will is invalid for:

• lack of testamentary capacity (the signer lacked mental ability to make a will),
• undue influence (someone pressured the decedent into signing),
• improper execution (statutory formalities not followed), and
• fraud or mistake affecting consent.

These grounds are often raised together because proof of forgery may overlap with other defects.

5. What proof does the court expect?

To convince a judge that a document is forged, you will typically need strong evidence:

• the original document (or good evidence of its absence),
• handwriting/signature analysis from a qualified examiner,
• witness testimony from people who observed the signing or can testify about the decedent’s signature habits, mental state, and relationships,
• medical records showing incapacity near the time of signing, and
• communications or financial records showing someone benefited and had motive to forge the will.

Note: courts weigh evidence and credibility; outcomes depend on the strength of proof and testimony.

6. Criminal vs. civil remedies

Forgery is also a criminal offense in Utah. Reporting suspected forgery to local law enforcement or the county prosecutor can prompt a criminal investigation. Criminal charges are separate from the probate contest and have different standards and outcomes. For Utah criminal law resources: https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title76/76.html.

7. Potential outcomes

If the court finds the will is forged or otherwise invalid, the court may:

• refuse to admit that will (or revoke its prior admission),
• apply an earlier valid will if one exists, or
• apply intestate succession rules if no earlier valid will exists.

The court may also award costs or attorneys’ fees in limited circumstances, but fee awards are not guaranteed.

8. Time limits and paperwork

Statutes and court rules set filing deadlines, notice requirements, and procedural steps for contests and probate. Because missed deadlines can bar a challenge, act quickly and consult local rules. See the Utah Legislature’s code search at https://le.utah.gov/xcode/ and the Utah Courts probate instructions at https://www.utcourts.gov/howto/probate/.

9. When to hire an attorney

Contesting a will is often procedurally complex and factually contested. If the estate has significant assets, if assets are being distributed, or if the forgery suspicion is serious, consider hiring a probate litigator experienced in will contests. The Utah State Bar has referral resources: https://www.utahbar.org/.

Helpful hints

• Act fast. Probate contests have procedural deadlines and assets can be distributed quickly.
• Preserve originals. Keep the original will if you can; if not, document chain-of-custody and who has possessed the document.
• Document everything. Record conversations, names of witnesses, copies of correspondence, medical and financial records, and any evidence the signer’s signature changed.
• Use experts. Handwriting examiners and medical experts can be critical in demonstrating forgery or incapacity.
• Consider criminal referral. A criminal investigation can produce evidence usable in probate court, but criminal processes are separate and may take longer.
• Seek a temporary stop to distribution. Ask the probate court to freeze distribution while you pursue the contest to avoid irreversible transfers.
• Talk to the probate clerk. Clerks can explain filing steps and local forms but cannot give legal advice.
• Get legal help for court filings. Properly framed pleadings, notices to interested parties, and evidence rules are important; a lawyer can help you avoid procedural errors that could dismiss your challenge.

Resources

• Utah Legislature — Utah Code (search all statutes): https://le.utah.gov/xcode/
• Utah Courts — Probate how-to and forms: https://www.utcourts.gov/howto/probate/
• Utah State Bar — public resources and lawyer referral: https://www.utahbar.org/
• Utah Criminal Code (Title 76) — offenses including forgery: https://le.utah.gov/xcode/Title76/76.html