Recovering Sentimental Items from a Sibling During Probate in New Mexico

How to recover personal or sentimental items from a sibling while an estate is open in New Mexico

Short answer: You can often force the return of sentimental personal property taken or withheld by a sibling during probate, but the route depends on who currently controls the estate, whether a personal representative (executor/administrator) is appointed, and whether the items are specifically listed in a will. Options include asking the personal representative to demand turnover, filing a motion in probate court to compel distribution, or bringing a separate civil action (for replevin or conversion). The steps below explain how recovery usually works under New Mexico procedures and what proof you will need.

Overview of probate control and who has authority

When someone dies, a probate court process typically gives authority over the decedent’s property to a personal representative (called an executor or administrator). That representative has a legal duty to collect assets, preserve them, inventory them, and distribute them according to the will or New Mexico intestacy rules. If a sibling took items while the estate was open or is refusing to return items that belong to the estate or that were bequeathed to you, the personal representative should act to recover them.

For general information on how probate works in New Mexico, see the New Mexico Courts probate information: https://www.nmcourts.gov/probate/. For statutory authority governing probate generally, see the New Mexico statutes pages (NMSA, Chapter 45 — Probate Code) at the New Mexico Legislature: https://www.nmlegis.gov.

Typical paths to recover sentimental items

Ask the personal representative to act.

If a personal representative is in place, they have the first responsibility to recover missing estate property. Give them written notice describing the items, any evidence you have that they belong to the decedent or to you (receipts, photos, witness statements), and a clear request that they recover and return the items or list them on the estate inventory.
Demand letter to the sibling.

If no personal representative is in place or the sibling refuses, send a written demand directly to the sibling. Describe the items, explain why you or the estate owns them, and state a deadline for return. Keep copies of everything. A demand letter often resolves disputes without court involvement.
File a motion in probate court (turnover or accounting).

If the estate is open in probate, you can ask the probate court to require the personal representative (or an estate custodian) to locate and recover missing property and to order a specific distribution if the will lists the items or identifies them by description. You can also file objections to the estate inventory if items are missing or improperly withheld. Probate court has direct authority over estate property and parties involved in the estate administration.
Bring a civil action for replevin or conversion.

If you have title or a right to immediate possession independent of the probate (for example, the decedent gave you an item before death, or the will explicitly gives you a particular item), you may file a replevin action to recover specific personal property or a lawsuit for conversion. Replevin is designed to return the exact item quickly; conversion is a claim for money damages when return is not possible.
Criminal or enforcement options (when applicable).

If a sibling stole the items, you may be able to involve law enforcement on theft charges. Criminal remedies are separate from civil/probate remedies but can be an avenue if the facts support criminal conduct.

What you need to prove ownership or right to possession

Photos showing you with the items or the items in your possession before the decedent’s death.
Receipts, appraisals, insurance records, or serial numbers tied to you or the decedent.
Testimony or written statements from witnesses who can confirm where the items were kept or who owned them.
Provisions of the will or written gifts that identify the items (if the will names specific items, give that page to the personal representative and the court).

Timing and urgent steps

Act quickly. Personal property can be moved or altered. If you fear the items will be hidden or destroyed, a replevin action or an emergency motion in probate to prevent removal may be appropriate. Keep a clear chain of communications, and document all contacts and efforts to recover the property.

Common legal outcomes

The probate court orders the personal representative to recover and deliver the items to you or to list them on the inventory for distribution.
A civil replevin order returns the exact items to you.
A conversion judgment awards money damages when items cannot be returned.
The court may award attorney fees or costs in some circumstances depending on the claims and statutes or court rules invoked.

When to consult an attorney

Talk with an attorney if the factual or legal issues are contested, if the value or identity of items is disputed, if the sibling denies they have the items, or if the probate process is stalled. An attorney can help you file the correct motion (turnover, accounting, objection to inventory) or pursue a replevin action in the appropriate court. If you cannot afford an attorney, check the New Mexico Courts self-help resources or your county’s legal aid offices.

Statutes and official resources

New Mexico’s probate procedures and the responsibilities of personal representatives are governed by the New Mexico statutes and the New Mexico Uniform Probate Code provisions. For statutory language and specifics, consult the New Mexico Legislature and the Judicial Branch:

New Mexico Judicial Branch — Probate information: https://www.nmcourts.gov/probate/
New Mexico Legislature (NMSA) — home page for searching statutes, including probate chapters: https://www.nmlegis.gov

Helpful Hints

Start with clear documentation: photos, receipts, witness statements.
Contact the personal representative in writing first; include a clear description and a reasonable deadline to return items.
Preserve evidence: don’t confront the sibling in ways that risk escalation or loss of evidence.
If the estate is open in probate, focus on probate remedies (motions to compel, objections to inventory) because the probate court controls estate property.
If you need the items immediately, ask an attorney about an emergency replevin or temporary restraining order to prevent removal or destruction.
Keep emotions out of communications; courts respond to facts and documentation, not sentiment.
Check court forms and instructions at the New Mexico Judicial Branch before filing anything yourself: https://www.nmcourts.gov/probate/.

Disclaimer: This article explains general legal principles for New Mexico and is for educational purposes only. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. For specific legal advice about your situation, consult a licensed attorney in New Mexico.

FastCounsel