FastCounsel

Detailed Answer

What a medical lien is: A medical lien is a legal claim a medical provider, hospital, or insurer can assert against money you recover from a third party (for example, in a personal injury settlement or jury award). The lien says: if you get paid by someone else for your injuries, the provider or payer can be paid from that recovery to cover the medical bills it paid or the benefits it provided.

Kinds of claims that can affect your recovery in Massachusetts:

• Provider or hospital liens / claims for payment: Some hospitals or providers may claim a lien or otherwise assert a right to be paid from a settlement. Massachusetts providers and hospitals commonly seek payment when they treated injuries caused by another party.
• Private-insurer subrogation and reimbursement: If a private health insurer (or ERISA plan) paid for your care, the plan may have a contractual or plan-based right of subrogation or reimbursement — that is, the insurer can seek repayment from any third-party recovery. Federal ERISA law can affect how these rights are enforced.
• MassHealth (Medicaid) recovery and third‑party liability: If MassHealth paid for your medical care, the program has a statutory right to recover from third-party recoveries. MassHealth’s Third Party Liability Unit handles these claims. See MassHealth TPL information: https://www.mass.gov/info-details/masshealth-third-party-liability-tpl
• Medicare liens and conditional payments: If Medicare paid for treatment, federal law (the Medicare Secondary Payer rules) requires Medicare to be repaid from your settlement for any payments that Medicare made that should have been paid by the at-fault party. See the Medicare Secondary Payer statute: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2018-title42/html/USCODE-2018-title42-chap7-subchapXVIII-sec1395y.htm

How medical liens and subrogation claims affect your settlement:

1. They reduce the money you actually get. Liens and subrogation claims generally must be resolved before or at the time you receive settlement funds. The practical result: your gross recovery is typically reduced by (a) attorney fees and costs, and (b) amounts that must be paid to providers or payers. Whether liens are paid out of the gross settlement or from the client’s net share depends on agreements and local practice—so get clarity in writing.
2. Priority and timing matter. Priorities vary: some statutes or plan rules give the public payer (MassHealth, Medicare) strong rights to recovery. Private insurer subrogation can be governed by contract or ERISA rules. Hospitals and providers may have statutory lien procedures or common-law claims. Timely notice and proper documentation affect whether a lien is valid and enforceable.
3. Negotiation is common and often effective. Many payers and providers will negotiate their lien or subrogation demand. Negotiation may reduce the amount paid, especially after accounting for attorney fees and case risks. Some payers discount claims if collection would be uncertain or if legal costs would be high.
4. Failure to resolve liens before settling can create risk. If you settle and then a provider or payer asserts a lien, you may face collection demands or even lawsuits against you. Some settlements include an escrow holdback to resolve outstanding lien claims before funds are released to you.

Hypothetical example (illustrative):

Say you settle a car-crash case for $100,000. Your attorney’s fee (contingency) is 33% ($33,000). Costs are $2,000. A hospital that treated you claims $20,000, and your private insurer says it paid $25,000 and wants reimbursement. How this breaks down depends on the enforceability and priority of each claim, and on whether the insurer or hospital will accept less:

• If liens and subrogation are paid from the gross recovery, one possible distribution is: attorney fee $33,000; hospital $20,000; insurer $25,000; costs $2,000; leaving you $20,000.
• If you successfully negotiate reductions (e.g., insurer accepts $15,000 and hospital accepts $10,000), your share could be higher.
• Sometimes attorney fees are allocated on the net (after lien payments) — that allocation can materially change what you receive. That is why understanding the legal priority and negotiating lien amounts are essential.

Steps you should take in Massachusetts:

1. Get a full accounting in writing. Ask each provider, insurer, and MassHealth for a written statement of the amount they claim and the basis for it.
2. Ask your attorney to verify enforceability and priority. Different claims have different legal bases. An attorney can check whether a provider has properly filed a lien or whether MassHealth/Medicare has a valid recovery claim.
3. Negotiate reductions where possible. Many payers accept a reduced lump-sum payment to release their claim. This often yields a better result for the injured person than paying the full billed amounts.
4. Consider escrow or holdback at settlement. If lien claims remain unresolved, put disputed funds in escrow until claims are resolved, rather than releasing all funds to the plaintiff immediately.
5. Document any agreement in writing. Get written release or satisfaction from any provider or insurer that accepts payment. Without a written release, the claim could resurface later.

Practical tips about specific payers:

• MassHealth: MassHealth has a Third-Party Liability (TPL) process and a statutory right to recover from third-party recoveries. Contact MassHealth’s TPL unit or have an attorney do so. (MassHealth TPL: https://www.mass.gov/info-details/masshealth-third-party-liability-tpl)
• Medicare: Medicare requires repayment for conditional payments under federal law. Check the Medicare secondary payer rules and request a conditional payment amount early in settlement negotiations. (Medicare statute: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2018-title42/html/USCODE-2018-title42-chap7-subchapXVIII-sec1395y.htm)
• Private insurers / ERISA plans: ERISA governs many employer plans; ERISA plans can be powerful but are subject to federal rules that may limit recoveries or require equitable resolution in federal court.

When to get a lawyer:

If you face multiple liens, large government payer claims (MassHealth, Medicare), or a complicated fact pattern (e.g., disputed liability or multiple insurance policies), hire an attorney who regularly handles settlements and subrogation. An experienced lawyer can:

• Identify all potential claimants and statutory obligations.
• Obtain accurate payoff figures and conditional payment amounts.
• Negotiate lien reductions and structure holdbacks or escrow.
• Draft settlement language that protects you from future claims.

Important note on timing: Start the lien and payoff process early. Request conditional payment letters (Medicare), MassHealth payoff figures, and written statements from providers well before you sign settlement documents. That minimizes surprises and preserves negotiating leverage.

Helpful Hints

• Do not sign or accept a settlement until you know who is claiming a lien and how much they demand.
• Ask for lien/payoff statements in writing and check whether they include interest, collection fees, or attorney charges.
• Remember billed charges are not the same as what a provider or insurer will legally be able to collect; billed amounts are often negotiable.
• For Medicare, request a conditional payment report early via the Medicare Secondary Payer Recovery Contractor (MSPRC) process to learn what Medicare believes it paid.
• If MassHealth paid for care, contact MassHealth’s Third‑Party Liability unit (see: https://www.mass.gov/info-details/masshealth-third-party-liability-tpl) so you know what recovery claim to expect.
• Insist on written releases from any entity you pay; a release prevents later collection actions on the same claim.
• Keep settlement funds in escrow if lien claims are unresolved. That protects you from having to pay out of pocket later.

Where to find more information and help in Massachusetts:

• MassHealth Third Party Liability information: https://www.mass.gov/info-details/masshealth-third-party-liability-tpl
• Federal Medicare Secondary Payer statute and rules (useful for Medicare-paid claims): https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2018-title42/html/USCODE-2018-title42-chap7-subchapXVIII-sec1395y.htm
• Consider consulting a Massachusetts personal-injury attorney or an attorney experienced with subrogation and lien resolution before you finalize any settlement.

Disclaimer: This article explains general principles about medical liens and settlements for educational purposes only and does not provide legal advice. It does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws and procedures change; consult a Massachusetts-licensed attorney for advice tailored to your situation.