FastCounsel

Detailed answer — how diminished value claims work in Indiana

Diminished value is the loss in a vehicle’s market value that remains after repairs following a collision. Even when your car is repaired to look and run like new, buyers typically pay less for a vehicle with a collision history. In Indiana, you can seek recovery for diminished value primarily in two ways:

• Third‑party claim: Demand diminished value payment from the at‑fault driver’s liability insurer. This is the most common route when another driver caused the crash.
• First‑party claim: Ask your own insurer to cover diminished value if your policy includes that coverage. Many personal auto policies do not expressly pay diminished value, so check your policy language.

Typical step‑by‑step process

1. Report the collision: Notify both insurers as required. If another driver was at fault, promptly report the claim to their insurer and your own insurer (if required by your policy).
2. Document the vehicle’s pre‑loss and post‑loss condition: Preserve the police report, photos from the scene, pre‑accident photos (if available), repair estimates, receipts for parts and labor, and a copy of the repair order.
3. Get a market value baseline: Establish the vehicle’s fair market value immediately before the accident using reliable sources (comparable sale listings, Kelley Blue Book or NADA values, dealer quotes, or independent appraisals).
4. Obtain a diminished value appraisal: Hire an independent appraiser or obtain a dealer/dealer appraiser opinion that estimates the post‑repair market value and calculates the difference from the pre‑loss value.
5. Prepare a written demand: Send a demand letter to the at‑fault insurer attaching all documentation (valuation, repair invoices, photos, police report, and appraisal). State the amount you are seeking and explain how you calculated it.
6. Negotiate: Expect back‑and‑forth with the insurer. They may accept, reject, or make a counteroffer. Keep all communications in writing and document phone calls.
7. If needed, escalate: If negotiations fail, options include filing a complaint with the Indiana Department of Insurance, using any policy appraisal or arbitration clauses (if your policy provides), or filing a lawsuit in civil court before the applicable statute of limitations runs.

Who pays and when

If another driver is at fault, that driver’s liability carrier should pay reasonable diminished value proven by your documentation. If you accept a full cash settlement from your own insurer for “full value” without preserving subrogation rights, you might waive the right to pursue diminished value against the at‑fault party—read any settlement carefully and get legal advice before signing.

Timing and deadlines

Act promptly. Evidence (photos, repair records, market listings) is strongest right after repairs. Also be mindful of Indiana’s lawsuit deadlines for property damage claims; these deadlines limit how long you can wait to sue. For general civil law and limitation guidance, consult Indiana statute resources: https://iga.in.gov/legislative/laws/2024/ic/titles/34 and contact the Indiana Department of Insurance for consumer assistance: https://www.in.gov/idoi/.

Practical points under Indiana law

• Indiana does not have a single statute that creates a unique diminished value remedy separate from ordinary property‑damage law. Diminished value claims follow normal property damage principles and insurance law.
• Insurer practices are regulated by the Indiana Department of Insurance. If you suspect bad faith or unfair settlement practices, you can file a complaint with the Department: https://www.in.gov/idoi/.
• Policies vary. Some insurers will evaluate diminished value as part of a property damage claim; others will deny it or limit payment. Read your policy and any release you sign carefully.

Helpful hints

• Keep everything: photos, the repair order, receipts for aftermarket parts, and any written communications from insurers.
• Get a pre‑loss value baseline from multiple sources (Kelley Blue Book, NADA, dealer comps) before you accept a settlement.
• Order an independent diminished value appraisal or dealer trade‑in estimate to support your claim. An independent, written appraisal strengthens your position.
• Don’t sign a full release or accept a “total loss” offer without confirming it does not waive your right to pursue diminished value from the at‑fault party’s insurer.
• If the at‑fault insurer delays unreasonably or denies a reasonable diminished value demand, consider filing a complaint with the Indiana Department of Insurance (https://www.in.gov/idoi/) or speaking with an attorney about litigation and remedies.
• Be aware of deadlines. Preserve evidence and submit your demand promptly to avoid loss of rights under the statute of limitations—consult an attorney for precise deadlines that apply to your situation (see Indiana civil code resources at https://iga.in.gov/legislative/laws/2024/ic/titles/34).
• Consider cost vs. benefit. Small diminished value amounts may not justify the expense of litigation or expert fees. For larger losses, an attorney and expert appraisal can be cost‑effective.